What are the origins of the universe?
Did the creation of the world really happen in 7 days?
Or was there the Big Bang?
Who’s right about the origin of the world, the Church or science?
Is the Genesis account true? Should it be taken literally? Is it open to interpretation? Is the Bible wrong?

1 • The origin of the world according to the Bible
The first two chapters of Genesis (the first book of the Bible) contain the account of the creation of the world.
One curious fact jumps out right away: there are no fewer than two creation accounts. The first begins with the first verse of the first chapter (Gen 1:1); the second starts at the fourth verse of the second chapter (Gen 2:4).
Why this redundancy? Did the author’s hand slip?

(And besides, if it was a mistake, someone could have fixed it over the centuries… did no Jew or Christian ever think of that?)
To complicate things further, the two accounts are also quite different from each other! Among the many discrepancies, I’ll point out just these two:
- The division of creation into seven days appears only in the first account.
- In the first account, man is the last of the creatures God shapes (after creating “light” and everything else); in the second account, on the other hand, man is the first creature formed, and everything else is created around him.
Why these differences? Is one of the two accounts true and the other false? Or is neither one true?
And anyway, what does it even mean for the creation account to be true?
1.1 • Literary genres in the Bible
The Bible is made up of about seventy books, written over a period of roughly eight centuries.
So it won’t surprise you to learn that the texts it contains are very different from one another.
Just as in literature people talk about the three “classic” literary genres (epic, lyric, and drama), each book of the Bible likewise belongs to one (or sometimes more than one) specific literary genre: there are historical books, wisdom books, prophetic books, poetic books, narrative books, etc.
A literary genre is a horizon of reading expectations: it tells me what to expect from a book or a piece of writing. It shapes my attitude toward the text.
So the first step in reading a book of the Bible correctly is to identify its proper literary genre, so as not to misunderstand the meaning of the text right under our noses.

1.2 • Genesis: what does it mean?
Question #1: Is Genesis a history book? Did the author mean to write a chronicle of the event of creation?
Most likely not.
Question #2: Does the fact that the book of Genesis isn’t a history book mean it’s false?
Of course not.
Question #3: What is the author’s intent in the Genesis text?
(Without droning on too much) the creation account in Genesis is a symbolic text that tells truths about God and the world, about human nature, and about sin; however, to be fully understood, it needs what’s called exegesis, that is, a correct interpretation of the text.
1.3 • Exegesis (and heresy-gesis)
Just to be precise: this “rule” of exegesis obviously doesn’t apply only to Genesis.
Some books of the Old Testament, for example, belong to a genre we could call “narrative” (bear with me on the term): stories that don’t convey a historical truth but a paradigmatic one. Examples are the books of Jonah, Tobit, Judith, and Job.
What do I mean by “paradigmatic truth”?
I mean that the Church’s Tradition hands these books down to us mainly because they present models of virtuous lives, examples of an attitude open to listening to God.

The Jewish community often used these narrative devices: they were part of its culture.
Jesus Himself used them: just think of the parables He told (does it really make sense to ask whether “the Good Samaritan” or “the Prodigal Son” actually existed?).
Disclaimer #1: this does NOT mean these texts are false! Quite the opposite: they’re dripping with truth, but truth of a different kind, one that has little to do with a news report or a documentary.
In short, not every passage in the Bible should be taken literally.
Disclaimer #2: this does NOT mean that EVERY passage in the Bible should be read allegorically, or else we end up with nonsense like…

Just to give an example: the Gospels, unlike the book of Job, have the character of a chronicle. The prologue of Luke’s Gospel is steeped in the historiographical approach found, for example, in the Histories of Herodotus of Halicarnassus (the so-called “father of history”) or in Thucydides‘s History of the Peloponnesian War.
The Gospels aren’t an allegorical tale, but “reportage”.
But let’s not open too many parentheses… in fact, let’s get back to the origins of the world…
…and to the guy I showed in the first picture (next to Albert Einstein): Georges Lemaître.
2 • Georges Lemaître
Version #1: Georges Lemaître (1894-1966) wakes up in the morning, has breakfast, takes a shower, and then starts his research in the lab: Georges is a Belgian physicist and astronomer.
He went down in history because in 1927 he published the hypothesis of the primeval atom, known today as the Big Bang theory.
Version #2: Georges Lemaître wakes up in the morning, makes the sign of the cross, opens his breviary, prays the Office of Readings, and then goes into the church to celebrate Mass: Georges is a Belgian priest.
Who on earth is this man? A scientist? A priest? A paradox? Fake news?
No, it’s no hoax! (Go ahead and check good old Wikipedia.)
Georges Edouard Lemaître was born in Belgium (in Charleroi) on July 17, 1894.
Although he had already decided on the consecrated life at the age of nine, his father asked him to put university studies before the seminary.
So Georges began a course of study in the sciences that culminated in 1920 with a doctorate in mathematics and physics (his dissertation advisor was none other than Charles Jean de la Vallée-Poussin… the “prime number theorem” guy).
That same year, he was finally able to enter the seminary.
During his years of formation, his superiors let him devote his free time to study, and Georges took the opportunity to dig into the work of the various scholars working on the theory of relativity: Albert Einstein, Arthur Eddington, Wolfgang Pauli, Théophile De Donder, etc.
In 1923, he was ordained a priest.
3 • The Big Bang
In 1927, Lemaître formulated a cosmological model in which the radius of the universe grew exponentially over time.
With this model, it was possible to derive a mathematical relationship between the distance and the velocity of galaxies (two years later, Edwin Hubble reached the same results when he formulated the law that bears his name).

(Correction: I wrote this blog page in 2019; a few years later, though, I found out that in 2018 the International Astronomical Union recommended renaming the “Hubble law” the “Hubble–Lemaître law,” in recognition of the Belgian priest’s fundamental contribution to cosmology. If you want to learn more, check out this link)
In 1931, Lemaître stated that it would be possible to describe the origin of the universe using the laws of thermodynamics and quantum mechanics.
In the following years, he developed this idea, which culminated in his model of the “primeval atom”: a “kernel” (about thirty times bigger than the Sun) containing all the energy/matter of the universe.
According to the model, the disintegration of this atom would have given rise not only to the universe, but to the very concept of space-time.
Does that ring a bell?
Exactly: it’s what later became known as the Big Bang theory.
4 • A theory that’s a bit too… creationist?
Einstein wasn’t too convinced by this whole “primeval atom” business, because the idea seemed to suggest an initial creation.
Along with Einstein, other scientists thought the Big Bang theory presupposed a metaphysical conception of the origin of the universe, based on the creation of the world.
So much so that the term “Big Bang” wasn’t coined by Lemaître but by Fred Hoyle, who used it to poke fun at the priest’s model, describing it mockingly as a big “fireworks show”.
Later on, though, other major scientists confirmed Lemaître’s discovery (in the 1960s, Arno Penzias and Robert Woodrow Wilson discovered the so-called “cosmic microwave background radiation”; between 1965 and 1970, Roger Penrose and Stephen Hawking proved that an initial singularity is inevitable in standard cosmological models).
Little by little, the whole scientific community came around to Lemaître’s model, and gradually the idea of the Big Bang became part of our “basic” knowledge.
So much so that, way back when, Margherita Hack (*) was asked to explain what the Big Bang was on a kids’ TV show, and she answered:
(*) (Margherita Hack (1922-2013) was an Italian astrophysicist and science communicator; the asteroid 8558 Hack is named after her)
[…] it’s the biggest fart in the universe, and everything we can observe came out of it.
(MARGHERITA HACK, in a 2011 interview)
A “perceptive” line, in its own way, able to simplify a complex concept with an analogy, so that even a kid can understand it.

5 • Lemaître: humility and intellectual honesty
I think it’s important to stress that Lemaître had no intention of mixing the theological sphere with the technical-scientific one.
As the intellectually honest person he was, he always thought it important not to confuse these “two paths”:
There were two ways of arriving at the truth. I decided to follow them both. Nothing in my working life, nothing in what I have learned in my studies of either science or religion has ever caused me to change that opinion. I have no conflict to reconcile. Science has not shaken my faith in religion, and religion has never caused me to question the conclusions I reached by strictly scientific methods.
(GEORGES LEMAÎTRE, interviewed by Duncan Aikman, The New York Times, February 19, 1933)
Ipse dixit.
Although, to be fair, when I read that line it made me super salty.

Oh well… in the end, he was right to stay out of the pointless controversies of the “battle” between science and faith.
Which, in the end, is only “good” for picking fights.
So much so that in the 1930s he received a whole bunch of honors: in 1933 he was made a member of the Class of Sciences of the Royal Academy of Belgium; in ’34 he received the Mendel Medal from Villanova College in Pennsylvania and the Francqui Prize in Belgium; in ’35 he was made an honorary canon of the Chapter of Saint-Rombaut; that same year he received an honorary doctorate from McGill University in Montreal, and so on…
The age of the universe
(A mini-section I didn’t know where to put, so here it is; feel free to skip it)
Another funny thing I discovered is that in Lemaître’s day, the age of the universe was estimated to be about the same as that of the oldest rocks on Earth.
In the 1930s, though, he calculated that the universe was about 10 billion years old (an estimate that turned out to be very close to the one “accepted” today).
6 • Conclusion (and a bedtime quote)
To tie it all together: I find the head-on clash between the exegesis of Genesis and the scientific models that try to glimpse the origin of the universe pretty unfruitful.
Science has its own area of competence (and the scientific method its own well-defined field of application).
And the search for truth about the origin of the cosmos (whether we’re talking about the Big Bang, string theory, or whatever you like) is a beautiful thing.
But it has nothing to do with what Genesis is talking about.
I think Genesis has a wider view; a view that’s as true in the third millennium as it was in the 2nd century BC.
A timeless view, fixed on Someone’s desire for things to exist. On the kindness of this Someone toward creation. On a delight in how the work of His hands turned out. On the fact that things are good and it’s beautiful that they exist. And that man and woman (as beat-up as they may look) turned out really well.
I’ll close with another quote from Lemaître:
Both of them, the Christian and the non-Christian, strive to decipher the intricate palimpsest of nature, in which the traces of the various stages of the world’s long evolution are covered over and jumbled together. The believer perhaps has the advantage of already knowing that this enigma has a solution, that everything was written by an intelligent being, and that the problem of nature was posed in order to be solved, its difficulty being no doubt proportioned to the abilities of present and future humanity. This may not give him new resources for his research, but it will help him keep that healthy optimism without which such an effort could not last long.
(in O. GODART and M. HELLER, Les relations entre la science et la foi chez Georges Lemaître, in “Pontificia Academia Scientiarum, Commentarii,” vol. III, no. 21, p. 11)
salt
(Summer 2019)
Sources/insights
- DOMINIQUE LAMBERT, "Lemaître, Georges Edouard", in Dizionario enciclopedico di scienza e fede, Urbanian University Press - Città Nuova, Città del Vaticano - Roma, 2002, II, pp. 1909-1912
- Se poi non vi fidate del riferimento qui sopra perché è preso da un dizionario stampato «ner Vaticano», potete andare a leggere su Wikipedia... parola più parola meno, troverete le stesse informazioni!
