Is it possible that God has revealed Himself?

Share on social media:

1 • The God problem

Last summer, I wrote a short piece on the existence of God.

I argued that if the watch exists (the universe), then the Watchmaker (a Creator) might exist too.

I suggested that it’s plausible that behind the laws of physics there is a Lawgiver.

And on the flip side, as I tried to explain here, I don’t think it’s very scientific to say that “everything came about by chance.”

Well…

So…

…let’s pretend for a second that God exists!

Great!

…so what? What difference does it make to me?

Knowing that God exists still leaves me with a lot of questions – about Him and about my life:

  • What is the meaning of life?
  • Why is there evil in the world?
  • Why do we die?
  • Is there life after death?
  • Does freedom exist?
  • Are we “playthings of fate“?
vegetarians

2 • Facing the “Mystery”

In short, even granting that God exists:

[…] reason, at its peak, can come to grasp His existence, but once that peak is reached, it is as if reason fails: it cannot go any further.
The perception that mystery exists is the pinnacle of reason.

(LUIGI GIUSSANI, All’origine della pretesa cristiana, BUR Rizzoli, Milan 2020, p. 7)

It’s not a matter of “not being smart enough.”

God is an “unsolvable problem” – He was a thousand years ago, He is today, and He probably will be a thousand years from now:

God, as the proper and exhaustive object of human hunger and thirst, of the constitutive need of consciousness and reason, is indeed a presence perpetually looming on the human horizon, yet He always remains beyond it.
And the harder man presses on the accelerator of his search, the further this horizon recedes, shifts.
This experience is so structural that if we imagined a human being living on our planet a billion centuries from now, we would have to say that the question would ultimately present itself to him in exactly the same way, despite all the unpredictable differences in his living conditions.

(LUIGI GIUSSANI, All’origine della pretesa cristiana, BUR Rizzoli, Milan 2020, p. 6)

42, the answer to the question about the universe

3 • Attempts to answer the “big question”

I think the “God question” – or, if you prefer, “the Ultimate Question of Life, the Universe, and Everything” (I.Y.K.Y.K.) – is unsolvable.

But just because it’s unsolvable doesn’t mean it has nothing to do with me.

Quite the opposite!

There is no one who does not, in some way and even without thinking about it, identify an answer to the question of what ultimately constitutes them.
By the very fact that one lives for five minutes, one affirms the existence of something that ultimately makes those five minutes worth living; by the very fact that one goes on living, one affirms the existence of a quid that is ultimately the meaning one lives for.

(LUIGI GIUSSANI, All’origine della pretesa cristiana, BUR Rizzoli, Milan 2020, p. 9)

Most philosophers have devoted pages and pages to the question of the meaning of Everything.

And most religions came about for a similar reason: to provide an answer to the question about God and to the question about His (possible) “relationship” with human beings.

Cthulhu cultists nyarlathotep

Philosophy and religions (painting with a broad brush here) are a movement from the bottom up, in search of God.

An admirable attempt (though often mixed with errors).

But still limited.

Human.

4 • What if God took the initiative?

A few lines up, I wrote that the most man can do, using reason, is to come to intuit the Mystery.

And I wrote that philosophy and religions are a (commendable, if limited) attempt to “pierce the heavens.”

cultists sacrificing virgins

Alright.

The question of all questions: what if God took the initiative?

What if God decided to reveal Himself?

What if the Mystery chose to unveil itself?

What if the movement weren’t from the bottom up (as it is in religions and philosophy), but from the top down?

What if there were a theophany (that is, a manifestation of God)?

Buuut…

…is it possible for the Mystery to reveal itself?

Well… possible? It’s certainly possible!

In fact, not only is it possible, but I’d say it’s reasonable… after all:

Reason can say nothing about what the mystery can or cannot do: precisely in order to be true to itself, it cannot rule out anything the mystery might undertake.
[…]
If reason were to presume to impose a measure on the divine – for example, declaring it impossible for the divine to enter into the human game at all to sustain man on his journey – if it went so far as to deny revelation, that would be the ultimate, extreme form of idolatry, reason’s extreme attempt to impose on God its own image of Him.
Before anything else, it would be a supreme act of irrationality.

(LUIGI GIUSSANI, All’origine della pretesa cristiana, BUR Rizzoli, Milan 2020, p. 23)

5 • Is it possible that God has revealed Himself?

Let’s pretend that God reveals Himself.

How would that be different from the “human attempts” I talked about earlier (religion, philosophy, etc.)?

  • Human attempts require effort on man’s part; they demand performance; humanity’s search for God favors intelligent people (philosophers’ reasoning, for example, isn’t within everyone’s reach), well-off people (if you can’t make ends meet and you work ten hours a day, you don’t have time to sit down and reflect on God), and lucky people (those born on the “right side” of the world, where there’s at least a minimum of freedom of thought).
  • If, on the other hand, God takes the initiative, human effort takes a back seat; in this second case, God isn’t reserved for the smart, the rich, and the lucky, but is within reach of the dumb, the poor, and the losers, too.

(See LUIGI GIUSSANI, All’origine della pretesa cristiana, BUR Rizzoli, Milan 2020, pp. 35–36)

In the first case, “finding God” is a bit like solving an incredibly complicated equation…

…in the second case, “finding God” is a bit like running into someone and recognizing them.

recognizing God

Conclusion

[Setting limits on God’s action] is the exact mirror image of the childish prohibition man places on God against intervening in man’s own life.
It is the farthest latitude to which the idolatrous claim can be pushed: the claim, that is, to attribute to God whatever pleases reason or whatever reason decides.

(LUIGI GIUSSANI, All’origine della pretesa cristiana, BUR Rizzoli, Milan 2020, p. 136)

I believe that – yes – it is possible that God has revealed Himself.

It is plausible.

This possibility does not offend reason.

On the contrary, those who deny this possibility a priori almost always do so on the basis of ideological assumptions, because they presume to decide what God can or cannot do, without even knowing Him.

And in fact, the book of the prophet Isaiah puts these words in God’s mouth:

For my thoughts are not your thoughts,
neither are your ways my ways.

(Isaiah 55:8)

salt

(Spring 2022)

Sources/insights

Share on social media:

Do you like the blog?


Click the little cup to help me grow it!